Jehovah's Witnesses believe salvation requires ongoing obedience to
Jehovah's laws, participation in the preaching work, association with the
organisation, and enduring to Armageddon. They know the NWT says salvation
is "by grace through faith" (Ephesians 2:8), but they read "faith" as
"exercising faith" — an ongoing set of works. The arm-flapping never stops.
Use this analogy to make sola fide visible in 30 seconds. The parachute does the saving — the jumper only has to trust it and put it on. The arm flapping is sincere, hard, continuous effort — and it is completely useless because gravity is greater than effort. Judgment Day is gravity: God's holiness is what you are falling toward, and no amount of field service will slow that fall. Christ is the parachute: he absorbs the impact in your place. Trust is not a second work you perform — it is the stopping of effort. You do not 'do faith'; you rest in the one who has done everything. Once the JW sees the analogy, pivot to and in the NWT, both of which use the past tense ("you HAVE BEEN saved") and explicitly deny works-basis ("NOT by works of righteousness"). Then ask the two questions from repentance-faith-gospel: "Do you know you have everlasting life right now?" and "If salvation were a free gift, would that be good news?"
Faith is not another work you add to your existing works. It is the ceasing of works — the transfer of trust from yourself to Christ. The parachute does not save you by how hard you believe in it. The parachute saves you because the parachute is a parachute. Faith is not strong because it is intense; it is strong because Christ is strong.
But faith without works is dead — James 2:26.
Exactly right — a dead person cannot flap either. James is asking "What does real faith look like?" not "How do you get saved?" If a man truly believes the parachute will save him, he puts it on — that is the 'work' James is describing. But the parachute still does all the saving. gives the order: saved BY grace THROUGH faith, created FOR good works. Works are the fruit, not the root.
But Jesus said 'exercise faith in me' — that's ongoing.
Ongoing trust is not the same as earning. A married couple lives in ongoing love, but the wedding happened once. Justification is the wedding; sanctification is the ongoing life. The NWT at says "you HAVE BEEN saved" — perfect tense, completed action. You do not re-jump out of the plane every day.
We don't trust in works — we trust in Jesus' ransom sacrifice plus obey Jehovah.
I want to press gently on the 'plus.' A parachute plus arm-flapping is not 'mostly parachute.' It is distrust of the parachute. says "You who are trying to be justified by law have been alienated from Christ; you have fallen away from grace." Paul's warning is that trusting Christ 'plus' anything is trusting Christ zero. Would you be willing to stop flapping — just for a moment — and see whether the parachute holds?
That analogy is too simplistic — salvation is more complex than jumping out of a plane.
The gospel is genuinely simple — that is the scandal of it. Paul says in that his fear is the 'simplicity that is in Christ' being corrupted. The Philippian jailer asked in , 'What must I do to be saved?' Paul did not give him a 12-week Bible study. He said, 'Believe in the Lord Jesus Christ, and you will be saved.' Jesus also told a dying thief, 'Today you will be with me in Paradise' () — no time for complexity there. The analogy is simple because the gospel is simple.
But salvation requires taking in knowledge — John 17:3 in the NWT.
The NWT at says 'This means everlasting life, their taking in knowledge of you' — most translations read 'that they may know you.' The Greek word is ginōskō, and biblical 'knowing' is relational, not a data-gathering exercise. Adam 'knew' his wife (). Jesus will say to some, 'I never knew you' () — not because he lacked information, but because there was no relationship. is not saying 'accumulate facts until you qualify.' It is saying 'eternal life IS knowing the Father and the Son' — the life is the knowing. You cannot stockpile your way into a relationship; you enter it by trust.
Don't let the analogy become the argument. The analogy is a door-opener; the actual work is Ephesians 2:8–9 and the two-question pivot from repentance-faith-gospel. Also, don't mock the arm-flapping — it costs the JW everything, and many JWs are genuinely exhausted by it. The analogy should offer relief, not a gotcha. Finally, watch for the NWT rendering 'exercise faith' (their mistranslation of pisteuō in John 3:16, John 5:24, etc.). When they quote those verses, point out that every other major translation simply reads 'believe' — the Watchtower added 'exercise' to turn a stative verb into a continuous work. The NWT itself gives you the fix at Ephesians 2:8: 'you HAVE BEEN saved' — perfect tense, done deal.
Practise telling the parachute story aloud until it takes about thirty seconds and sounds like you, not a script, and gentle, because the arm-flapping costs the Witness a great deal. Then read and with its surrounding verses in the NWT on jw.org, noting the completed "you have been saved" and the "not by works" wording you will point to. Look up and in the NWT as well, so "exercise faith" and "taking in knowledge" don't catch you off guard. Rehearse the reply until "works are the fruit, not the root" comes naturally, and memorise the two follow-up questions about everlasting life and a free gift.